Tilda's Bake Shop

Beautiful cakes, pies, cookies... everything you expect in a good bakery. Helpful staff, bright and clean shop packed with goodies.

They made a beautiful and delicious cake for my bridal shower! I would definitely order from them again.

My wife's favorite bakery. We have to go here Everytime we are in town. She lives the crumbcake pastries.

Get here early , especially on the weekend because they sell out of many things very quickly. Like Muffins LOL.

Great bakery items

Great bakery but slow service

Cannoli's out of this world! Clean, bright & fresh. Great variety of baked goods. Parking is a little tricky.

Excellent pastries & service

Great jelly donuts and crumb buns. Pastries are also over the top!

They open early and the pastries are wonderful. Everyone in my family loves it!

I love in shoreham and I love Tilda's! I always buy my cakes, pies, pastries, etc. For 15 yrs now and it's the best bakery I have hands down. Tilda's can be busy but they are worth waiting on the weekends for. My husband loves the cheeaecake, My son the creampuffs, and I love the pinoli cookies! We love everything but those are the favs. The bread is amazing! I love Tilda's and never have anything but compliments from guests at my home and we only go to Tilda's even if we moved , we would make the drive to come back that's how awesome they are. I wish they had bakery nominations because I would nominate them! Keep up the great 👍 work !

Old school and newer things. Dounuts,cookies,eclairs etc. The best on long island.

The BEST bakery on Long Island. Always fresh pies cakes and cookies and clean. Especially around the holidays, when the lines are out the door, they keep it moving smoothly and the staff is great.

We have ordered birthday cakes here for the past 2 years. The first year they gave us the wrong cake altogether, someone else’s cake. When we got the correct cake, it was great. This year they simply made the wrong cake, albeit it was still delicious, just not what we ordered. We will not order cakes from them anymore, perhaps we’ll enjoy their donuts on sundays, they cant screw up a donut order with me standing there, or can they?;) if they do I’ll be sure to tell you about it

Neighborhood staple..good pastry

Best bakery around!

There's a bakery around the corner from my house, yet I still drive 12 MILES to Tilda's. That's how good the stuff is.

My family loved the cake. And the young man who helped us was really sweet and helpful.

Place is a goldmine, always fresh and they have a great assortment of goodies!

Always so friendly with yummy goodies and reasonable prices!

The Best of all home style bakery on Long Island

Long lines but well worth the wait, 🍪🍩 🥧 🍫🎂♥️

The only place to go for fresh bakery items!! Their creme filled donuts are to die for!

Nice very helpful staff, cheesecake it's amazing will definitely return in the future

How sweet it is!

Cookies and cake are the best judge for how good a bakery is and most places make tasteless and crumble-in-your-hand desserts but not Tilda's!! Since moving t Suffolk county I had never found a good bakery until now. Tilda's is totally worth the hike!

The best in 4 towns fast service the cook in the back in my book deserve 3 stars just needs better delivery service

It's just out of this world great try them if u have not

We got a gluten-free cake here for my sister's 40th birthday. Excellent. The shop has an extensive selection of pastries, cookies, pies and cakes.

I would say the best bakery on long Island, delicious pastries, bread, French baguette, just like back home in Europe.

I'm back home visiting and had to stop in and get some goodness

Absolutely delicious pastries.

A staple in the community. Fresh and delicious always.

Bakery is good. Prices are becoming higher and higher. Parents recently picked up some macaroon cookies. They were just ok. Was disappointed in them. But overall good place.

Excellent bakery

By far the best bakery in the area

Thank you! The two 1/2 sheet cakes for my mom’s 70th birthday party were delicious & beautifully decorated!! Compliments to the chef :) also thanks to the young lady that took my order- I expressed what I had in my mind for each cake & she must’ve shared every detail clearly because they were exactly what I hoped for in appearance!

The annual Christmas Eve line starts early in the AM, and is always out the door when you arrive but goes quicker than expected. Extra staff patiently help... The baked goods are luscious and gorgeous. A special part of my holidays every year!

Amazing baked goods! Took a cheesecake and cannolis home with me. Oh and dog treats!

The bakery is very clean and the employee I had was attentive and multi-tasking. I got dog treats and a pound of cookies. My dogs ate the treats but the cookies were bland and not good at all. I couldn't even finish one. The cakes and pastries did look good but with the taste of the cookies I don't think I will return.

Great variety fresh and delicious longtime customer

The selection wasnt as big as I thought it would be or maybe because it was at the end of the day around 4 PM. The stuff I did buy was very good quality and wasnt over priced like I expected and would definately reccomend to other....worth the trip.

great bakery

Everything I have purchased in this bakery is fantastic ! The employees are very helpful and friendly as well ! ❤️😊

Late in the day fewer selections